‘God was in that moment:’ Saint Peter’s University priests on Peacocks’ historic NCAA run
Was it a miracle?
“Astounding,” is how Father Andrew Downing, S.J., described it. He watched with delight as his small university men’s basketball team leaped into the national spotlight in a historic tournament run to the NCAA’s Elite Eight. It was the first time a college basketball team ranked so low went so far.
Call it a Cinderella story. Or a David versus Goliath moment. Whatever it was, Father Downing and the entire nation couldn’t get enough of their Saint Peter’s University Peacocks.
“It was miraculous in that no one, even most of us at the university, really thought we could go that far given our limitations and budget for our athletic programs,” said Father Rocco Danzi, S.J., parish administrator of St. Aedan’s: The Saint Peter’s University Church. “It’s pennies compared to the other bigger schools.”
In 2020 Saint Peter’s spent $7.2 million on all its sports programs compared with The University of Kentucky’s $138.3 million. The Peacocks felled Kentucky – a number two seed – 85-79 to ignite their tournament run on March 17.
Father Downing, vice president for Mission and Ministry and the director of Campus Ministry at Saint Peter’s, draws a Jesuit parallel to highlight the magnitude of the run.
Jesuit schools are some of the biggest names in college basketball, most prominently Gonzaga, which was a 1-seed this year. Among other notables are Georgetown, Xavier, Creighton, St. Louis, Marquette—even Loyola Chicago and Sister Jean have made headlines in recent tournaments.
“There are bigger [Jesuit] schools, there are more endowed schools, there are a lot of schools with more prestigious basketball programs…but it’s because of Saint Peter’s that for the fifth consecutive year in a row, a Jesuit school is in the Elite Eight,” Father Downing said. “Well, they were the most unlikely of those schools.”
Two days after beating Kentucky, the Peacocks took care of Murray State, who had entered the game on a 21-game winning streak. By the time Saint Peter’s held off 3-seed Purdue and strutted into the quarterfinals, the excitement reached a feverish pitch that held the nation captive.
So what is the great leveler between those with big pockets and those with small? Those with rare athletic ability and those diminutive in comparison? Is there something bigger going on? Father Danzi seems to think so. The answer comes from what he knows about Saint Peter’s head coach Shaheen Holloway, a Seton Hall, and St. Patrick High School (Elizabeth, N.J.) alum. Back when he was working at the university as vice president of Mission and Ministry four years ago, he met Coach Holloway at Holloway’s introductory press conference and spent some time speaking with him.
“What people don’t see is he’s an extremely spiritual man,” Father Danzi said. “He gathers the guys for prayer before a game or practice, and he’s very serious about that. He doesn’t want anyone else besides the team and his staff in the locker room [because] that moment is just for them, about them, but also about God.”
And when it came time to represent on the national stage, Saint Peter’s modeled its school and faith perfectly, said Father Danzi.
“Catholic values, care for others, formation of the whole person: body, mind, and spirit. We saw in those basketball players that Jesuit educational approach. We saw their prowess, their human strength, but there’s also something more in the way they cared for each other, respected each other, and worked together. It’s pretty inspiring.”
That inspiration touched millions who watched along as Saint Peter’s made its run. The overwhelming support, in turn, transformed the spirit of the small campus.
“There was a lot of joy and pride,” said Father Downing. “Pride in the best sense of the word. When the whole country is looking at your school and rooting for you, then all of a sudden, being proud that you are a Peacock takes on a whole new dimension.”
That national support reached its most incredible heights for the Sweet Sixteen and Elite Eight matchups in Philadelphia, both of which Father Downing attended.
“The Sweet 16 game was a lot of fun, a lot of energy,” he recalled. “Whether you were wearing something with Saint Peter’s or not, basically the whole stadium was rooting for us.”
Saint Peter’s tournament run ended abruptly Sunday with a loss to North Carolina. Having witnessed all the highs and the eventual conclusion, here is where Father Downing glimpses God in all of this: not in the many achievements but the togetherness of the team and its university.
“We were just going to show ourselves for who we were, and for me, that was the proudest moment,” he said. “I’d like to think that God was in that moment, allowing Saint Peter’s to show through its students.”
Father Downing said the Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia, where the team played their final two games, was overwhelming and he was impressed with the composure of the players.
“The arena here on campus is not an enormous facility, so to be playing in that arena in Philadelphia with all the lights and all the sound and all the spectators, I think those guys have to just be proud that they got to [where they did],” he said. “I’m looking forward to telling them that when I see them. I think there’s not a single person here on campus who wouldn’t say the same.”
Father Danzi certainly agrees.
“I want to thank them,” he said. “I needed that shot in the arm. My parish and people are amazing; we worked hard [to fight through] COVID. But I’m tired. It’s all hands on deck. We just needed a big dose of hope and to be able to smile again.”
Saint Peter’s supplied that hope and inspiration, not only to its parish and its school, but also to a fanbase that has grown beyond human imagination in 10 days. This team made a whole nation smile, and surely there is God in that.
Saint Peter’s University is affiliated with the Archdiocese of Newark and will be celebrating its 150th anniversary this weekend with Cardinal Joseph W. Tobin, C.Ss.R., the archbishop of Newark.
Featured image: Saint Peter’s University players react after defeating Murray State University 70-60 on March 19, 2022, gaining a spot in the tournament’s Sweet 16. Saint Peter’s went on to defeat Purdue University on March 25 in Philadelphia to become the first 15 seed to advance to the Elite Eight in tournament history. (CNS photo/Zach Bolinger, Icon Sportswire via St. Peter’s University)
